Not Quite Orthodox: Water Baptism Among Russian Evangelicals

Do you have the right view of water baptism? Many Russian evangelicals have unknowingly absorbed Russian Orthodoxy’s sacramentalism into their doctrine of water baptism. Departing from the doctrine of water baptism as an outward sign of an inward grace, many now treat it as a means of grace, rebirth, and salvation itself. But Scripture teaches that baptism is never part of the gospel; salvation comes by faith alone.

27 min read

PDF


Introduction

The Protestant Reformation spawned a multitude of disagreements about the doctrine of water baptism. But despite diverse opinions on the doctrine of water baptism, one common observation united all the debating parties: As they reexamined the teaching on the sacraments, each of them could clearly delineate a connection between water baptism and the gospel. This discussion is still relevant, particularly for Russian evangelical churches, for many Russian evangelicals have unknowingly abandoned the Bible’s teaching on water baptism and assumed Russian Orthodox views into their theology. In this article, I will trace the rise of evangelicalism in Russia apart from the influence of the Reformation and show how that lack of influence has impacted Russian evangelicalism’s doctrinal development. Next, I will explain the understanding of baptism in the Russian Orthodox Church and show how its doctrine has influenced Russian evangelical believers. Finally, I will point to a biblical alternative, clarifying specifically how water baptism benefits the believer.

The Development of the Russian Evangelical Doctrine of Water Baptism Apart from the Protestant Reformation

The Protestant Reformation of the 16th century had no impact on Russia. For all practical purposes, Russian Christianity was dominated by the Russian Orthodox Church. The teaching and restructuring of the church achieved by the Protestant Reformation did not affect the religion of the majority of Russians, and that lack of influence meant that Russian evangelicalism developed uniquely under the influence of Russian Orthodoxy. The doctrine of water baptism was particularly influenced by the doctrines of the Russian Orthodox Church.

Water Baptism and the Reformation

The Protestant Reformers were products of the medieval church, and they reacted to an array of ecclesiastical abuses. Moreover, each member of this diverse group of Reformers, interpreting Scripture apart from the established and approved ecclesiastical authority, tended to arrive at individualized interpretations, producing a diversity of interpretations for various doctrines. This is especially noticeable in the way they formulated church rulings on such issues as the Eucharist and baptism.

For example, Ulrich Zwingli and Balthasar Hubmaier collaborated in the city of Zurich, which supported the Reformation. In 1523, both expressed their dissatisfaction with the Catholic Church’s doctrine of infant baptism.1 But their paths then diverged.2 Zwingli formulated a new basis for the baptism of infants which he connected to the Covenant of Grace, Old Testament circumcision, and initiation into the people of God. Hubmaier, however, rejected infant baptism in favor of baptism upon confession of faith and thus was regarded as an Anabaptist (i.e., one who believes in rebaptism). He was burned at the stake in 1528 in Austria. After this, many Anabaptists were drowned (ironically called their third baptism) by both Catholics and Protestants alike due to their convictions on baptism.

Even though Luther, Calvin, Zwingli, and the great majority of Puritans greatly emphasized grace and faith, they failed to bring the Reformation to completion. Although they fought against sacramentalism, not all their positions on the Eucharist and baptism were satisfactory. While many of the Protestant denominations rejected an over-exalted view of the sacraments, many retained vestiges of medieval Catholicism’s sacramentalist distortions. We should not idealize the Reformers, and we should consider the historical context in which they lived and thought. Likewise, we should not be surprised to see similar distortions in the evangelical movement that later sprang up independently in Russia.

Water Baptism and the Evangelical Movement in Russia

Though Lutheranism penetrated the borderlands of Russia and provincial capitals, its presence was minimal. The influence of evangelical Christianity is connected instead to the 1860s, when an evangelical revival began simultaneously in three different parts of the Russian empire. That revival led to the formation of several evangelical denominations, which eventually joined as a unified movement.3 The beginning of Russian evangelicalism apart from any historical ties to the Protestant Reformation led to a sacramental understanding of baptism dominating the mindset of Russian evangelicals for centuries.

Early Evangelical Doctrine on Water Baptism

After experiencing spiritual revival, Russian evangelical believers were compelled to follow in the footsteps of the Anabaptists. Since they did not consider infant baptism, performed in the bosom of the Orthodox Church, effective, they were baptized again on profession of faith.4 Of course, this view of baptism and religion in general provoked resistance from the Russian Orthodox Church. Nevertheless, the people who were committed to the Scriptures instead of the traditions of the Church were prepared to take a stand for their faith.

Personal testimonies of evangelical believers as well as their official documents testify to their changed views on water baptism. For example, one of the leaders of the evangelical movement in St. Peterburg, Vasily Pashkov, wrote,

We do not become members of Christ’s Body through immersion in water, but in one Spirit we are baptized into one Body. The Body of Christ consists of all those who are born again who once were far off and have been brought near by the blood of Christ (Eph. 2:13). May God keep us from elevating baptism again to the level of a slogan.5

In similar fashion, Ivan Prokhanov, in the doctrinal statement of the Evangelical Christians, gives this definition of water baptism, which assumes the difference from spiritual baptism and contains no traces of sacramentalism:

Baptism by water is an external sign of baptism by the Holy Spirit completed beforehand in the soul and death to sin and resurrection to righteousness (Ro 6:3–4). Therefore baptism by water is significant only when it is performed for those who have consciously put their faith in Christ, repented, been converted and have been born again, i.e. who have received spiritual baptism (Mt. 28:19; Ac. 2:41; Mt. 3:1–2, 6; Ac. 2:38; 8:12; 10:47; 18:8; 19:5; Ga. 3:26–27; Mk. 16:16).6

The Cost of Biblical Conviction

Appraising the historical situation in the first decades of the evangelical movement in Russia, Viktor Ryaguzov concluded,

Russian Baptists paid dearly for their biblical stance on the issue of baptism. During the time of the tsars, laws were enacted that punished anyone who persuaded another person to leave the Russian Orthodox Church with hard penal labor. During the Soviet era those who were baptized were fired from their jobs or transferred to lower paid work, and those who baptized were put on trial if they baptized a minor. In this regard, Russian Baptists shared the fate of European Baptists who had to endure no small amount of suffering for the right to baptize new believers.7

Unfortunately, historical dedication to believer’s baptism itself is not always able to protect the evangelical church from later distortions and abuses. Despite fundamental differences in doctrine, Russian Orthodoxy influenced and continues to influence evangelical believers and their perceptions, including their understanding of water baptism.8

The Influence of Russian Orthodoxy on the Evangelical Understanding of Water Baptism

It is not hard to understand why the influence of the Russian Orthodox Church is noteworthy. Konstantin Prokhorov, analyzing the historical process, rightly notes, “Orthodox believers and Baptists, living in the same country, were bound inevitably to clash with one another. Many members of Baptist congregations spent a portion of their lives in the bosom of the Russian Orthodox Church. This phenomenon could not possibly go by without consequence.”9 However, in light of the colossal differences between the two denominations, any attempt to demonstrate a Russian Orthodox influence upon the Russian evangelical church requires carefully presented evidence and argumentation. The following subsections show such influence in the doctrine of water baptism by articulating the Russian Orthodox teaching on water baptism, identifying sacramentalist tendencies in Russian evangelicalism, and pointing out the real consequences of the Orthodox teaching on baptism.

Russian Orthodox Teaching on Baptism

Eastern Orthodoxy gives preference in the life of the church to sacred activities called sacraments. The church itself is considered, first of all, to be a “sacramental organism.”10 Water baptism, together with the Eucharist, is considered prominent among the seven sacraments accepted by Orthodoxy.11 The standard definition of this sacrament is:

The sacrament of baptism is a sacred activity whereby a believer in Christ . . . is cleansed from original sin as well as all sins committed by him before baptism, is born again by the grace of the Holy Spirit into new spiritual life (he is born spiritually) and made a member of the Church, that is, the blessed Kingdom of Christ.12

This definition demonstrates Orthodoxy’s basic understanding of baptism.13 First, baptism is viewed as a means of regeneration: The Holy Spirit mysteriously regenerates the one receiving baptism by means of water drawn from a baptismal font. But the Orthodox understanding of regeneration is not the same as the evangelical understanding. According to the Russian Orthodox Church, regeneration is considered to be a beneficial operation which provides only the opportunity to achieve salvation.14 Second, water baptism is a means of grace which leads to the forgiveness of sins, original and personal, and to the process of deification (also called theosis).15 But in Orthodoxy, the meaning of grace differs from its meaning in Protestantism. Russian Orthodox teaching understands grace to be a mysterious divine power or energy which enables a person to overcome a sinful beginning and to make progress toward deification.16 Third, it is precisely water baptism which is associated with a person’s entry into the true Orthodox Church, which refers not to joining the local church but to joining fellowship with the body of Christ.17

From the point of view of liturgy, baptism in the Orthodox Church includes a series of rituals including blessing the water in the baptismal font, multiple signings of the cross, exorcising demons from the water and the individual receiving baptism, etc. Immediately after the baptism, the sacrament of anointing with oil is performed, testifying to the giving of the gifts of the Holy Spirit to the person who has just joined the Church.18

Even on the basis of such a brief overview, it is not difficult to see that sacramentalism saturates Orthodox teaching on water baptism. Many concepts familiar to the evangelical believer have different definitions closely tied to Orthodoxy’s soteriological and ecclesiastical characteristics. Despite these variations, evangelical churches during the Soviet period were unable to avoid Orthodox influence.

Indications of Sacramentalism in Russian Evangelical Teaching on Water Baptism

It would not be accurate to say that Russian evangelical teaching on baptism changed due to the influence of Orthodoxy or that the Russian evangelical church as a whole considers baptism a sacrament. Nevertheless, definite traces of sacramentalism can be detected in the works of authoritative evangelical leaders and authors of the past. Prokhorov notes:

In contrast to the theological idea of Ulrich Zwingli, widely accepted among western (e.g., American and German) Baptists, separating the action of grace from church practices, many authoritative Russian Baptist authors after the Second World War and later right up to the time of perestroika were inclined to interpret certain church rites by no means only in symbolic terms but in the eastern tradition of apophatism and theological sacraments.19

Unfortunately, all the fundamental elements of the Orthodox understanding of baptism mentioned above are creeping into evangelical teaching on baptism. In order to be persuaded of this, we will turn our attention to several examples.

One of the most well-known leaders and preachers among Russian evangelical Christians, Nikolai Kolesnikov confirms this:

We realize that behind the outward form of the ministry which we do is an invisible, hidden spiritual meaning through which God Himself imparts the grace of His blessing. . . . Water is a necessary component during the performance of this commandment, but not the main one. The main component is being “born again” (John 3:3). . . . We all understand that baptism as an external rite does not save, but for the person who has experienced regeneration it is obligatory since it is actually an element of salvation. . . . So baptism is not merely a ritual which secures the right to participate in the Lord’s Supper but a necessary condition for membership in the body of Christ, the church (1 Cor 12:13).20

Similarly, Vitaly Kulikov, editor of Bratsky Vestnik (The fraternal messenger), the foremost evangelical Christian journal of the Soviet period, states, “It must be said that in baptism, we receive a special blessing. The Lord imparts to us the grace of the Holy Spirit and receives us into the church as His children.”21 Sergey Sannikov, a widely respected historian and theologian, emphasizes, “It’s as if baptism is the final point in the process of the conversion of a sinner and unites him with Christ, therefore it presents itself as an obligatory element of salvation.”22 Finally, Yury Sipko, one of the leaders of the Baptist brotherhood over the past decades insists, “In baptism, what Christ calls being born again is completed. Through baptism the saved individual enters into the local church, becoming a part of the mystical body of Christ.”23

The quotes cited above contain the key Orthodox elements of water baptism: rebirth, the grace of the Holy Spirit, and union with the body of Christ, the church. Their authors reject ritualism (devotion to external acts), yet they introduce sacramentalism (ascribing internal theological meaning) into their teaching on baptism. This caused Prokhorov to conclude, “So this is how Russian Baptists, at a certain point in their history, embarked on their own not quite Protestant and not quite Orthodox path in theology and everyday church life.”24

Consequences of Orthodox Teaching on Baptism

The influence of Orthodoxy could not persist without consequences. It has left its mark on both individual believers and local churches as a whole.

Influence on Individual Believers

With regard to the outlook and life of evangelical Christians, it is worth noting the following problems. First, despite the denials of the authors cited above, the transferal of the power of grace and spiritual rebirth to water baptism unavoidably leads to a trust in rituals and rites. The Russian Orthodox have not avoided this problem, nor have evangelical believers, experiencing the influence of sacramentalism, been “washed clean” of it.25 It is no surprise that in traditional Baptist churches, people not only get excited about baptism but are likewise enthusiastic about the dedication of children and the prayers uttered over them.

Second, the sacramental understanding of baptism grants a false assurance to those who have not experienced regeneration but who endeavor to join the church, having been falsely guaranteed salvation through the performance of a ritual rather than a genuine work of the Spirit. Once again, evangelical Christians have gone the way of Orthodoxy, coddling an illusion of salvation about which, for example, even Vladimir Martsinkovsky warned the Orthodox Church. Martsinkovsky, a Russian Orthodox, recognized the problem of false assurance and warned the hierarchy of the Russian Orthodox Church, but the Holy Synod refused to heed his warning. If an Orthodox believer noticed the issue of false assurance, evangelical believers must guard an even keener sense of awareness.26

Third, this “not quite Protestant and not quite Orthodox” view of baptism lays the groundwork for an attitude of pride based on the conviction that “we are special.” Unfortunately, similar claims to uniqueness and distinctiveness can be traced frequently in the comments of Russian Baptists. For example, Konstantin Prokhorov notes that, “Russian Baptists, baptized as adults and at the same time preserving many of the traits of eastern Christian thinking, often feel they acquire a particular mystical advantage while engaging in the sacrament.”27

Influence on the Church

The sacramental understanding of water baptism has also negatively affected the local church. First, flirting with Orthodoxy unavoidably leads to a corruption of the understanding of baptism,28 which in practice is expressed in two opposite tendencies. On the one hand, there is a reevaluation of the role of water baptism when it is made necessary for salvation; baptism, in fact, becomes a part of the gospel. On the other hand, there is the possibility of underestimating the role of water baptism with the result that some might attend church for years but delay their baptism, purposely putting it off for a more “convenient” moment.

Second, as Martsinkovsky observed, filling the church with those who “are being saved” through the ritual of baptism will end in the atrophy of congregations and their transformation into a “galvanized corpse,” since the “spiritual ascendency of the Church depended on the seriousness with which it accepted new members.”29

Finally, embracing Orthodox ideas contributes to the evangelical movement’s loss of identity. Periodic dialogue with Orthodoxy, understood as an integration of Eastern Christian ideas into the teaching and life of the evangelical church, is practiced intentionally and evaluated positively.30 But the tendency to water down views and thus blur the lines (between Baptist and Orthodox teaching) sometimes goes unnoticed due to an underestimation of the influence of the Orthodox Church. For example, the translators who translated Mark Dever and Paul Alexander’s book The Deliberate Church used the word svyashennodestvie (priestly ministry) to refer to such church ordinances as baptism and the Lord’s Supper.31

In summary, it is worth noting that, in and of itself, recognizing baptism upon confession of faith (believer’s baptism) does not shield the evangelical church from abuses. As in the Reformation, a difference of opinions about water baptism seriously concerns the doctrine of the church, in particular the question, “Is water baptism necessary for salvation?” In other words, is baptism a component of the gospel? Should every evangelistic sermon contain a call to baptism? Must every unbelieving person hear a clear warning that if he is not baptized, he cannot be saved, receive the forgiveness of sins, nor count on obtaining eternal life? Does the Lord save a person at the moment of baptism?32 Unfortunately many believers—Russian or otherwise—answer these questions in the affirmative. They have forgotten one of the key pillars of the Reformation: sola fide! If water baptism is a condition for salvation along with faith, then pastors and preachers must alter their approach to the preaching of the gospel by including a requirement to be baptized in water in order to receive salvation. But if salvation is a gift of God by faith alone, then the doctrine of baptism is preached appropriately when it is directed to those who have believed and when they are called to obey God’s command to be baptized.

Biblical Teaching Concerning Water Baptism

If Eastern Orthodoxy actually impacts how Russian evangelical believers perceive water baptism, then a reminder of the biblical teaching on water baptism is an important step in reorienting Russian evangelicals to proper emphases on rebirth, faith, and baptism.

The Essence of Water Baptism

Any conversation about water baptism makes no sense without a clear biblical definition. But it must be stipulated that whenever the Scriptures use the words “baptism” or “baptize,” they are not always referring to water baptism. This term did not immediately become “technical” or automatically associated with the Christian ceremony. This means that not all texts which are traditionally connected with water baptism actually refer to a physical baptism in water. Many commentators view almost every occurrence of the words “to baptize” (βαπτίζω) and “baptism” (βάπτισμα; βαπτισμός) in the New Testament epistles as referring to water baptism.33 This approach is based on the view that during the writing of the New Testament, the word group βαπτίζω, βάπτισμα, βαπτισμός came to be used commonly to denote the rite of initiation into the Christian faith.34

However, in light of the New Testament’s use of this word group, this point of view is hardly justified. Considering all uses of this root, we can safely say that the Scriptures talk about various kinds of baptism, or to be more exact, various kinds of immersion.35 Besides using the words “baptism” or “immersion” to refer to Christian baptism, the New Testament authors use these words to designate ritual washings (Heb 6:2; 9:10) and John’s baptism of repentance (Matt 3:1–2, 11; Acts 19:4), including the baptism of Christ (Matt 3:13–17) and the baptisms which Christ’s disciples performed (Matt 4:17; John 4:1–2). In addition, they were used for the baptism of suffering (Mark 10:32–39, esp. 38; Luke 12:50), baptism into Moses (1 Cor 10:2), baptism for the dead (15:29), baptism by fire (Matt 3:10–12), and spiritual baptism (3:11; Acts 1:5).36

Many of the types of baptism listed above have no connection with water baptism; they seldom have anything to do with water at all. Kenneth Boa writes, “There is more than one kind of baptism mentioned in the New Testament and . . . most of them are figurative.”37 Consequently, we can conclude that it is improbable that the word “baptism” came to be an established term indicating the rite of initiation into the Christian community. More likely, each occurrence of the word needs to be investigated separately in order to determine its meaning in a given context.38

So what is water baptism? It is a church ordinance which consists of an external, symbolic testimony to the beginning of Christian life and entrance into the Christian community.39 In other words, it is an external testimony of an internal change resulting from a union with Christ and His body, the church.

There are two verses which, at a minimum, should be added to the key biblical texts which establish water baptism as an ordinance: Matthew 28:19–20 and Acts 2:38, 41.

  • Matthew 28:19–20: “Go therefore and make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit, teaching them to observe all that I have commanded you. And behold, I am with you always, to the end of the age.” (ESV)
  • Acts 2:38, 41: “Peter said to them, ‘Repent and be baptized every one of you in the name of Jesus Christ for the forgiveness of your sins, and you will receive the gift of the Holy Spirit.’ . . . So those who received his word were baptized, and there were added that day about three thousand souls.”

Both texts speak about conversion, water baptism, and entry into the local church.

What Water Baptism Is Not

Having briefly explained what baptism is, it is imperative to mention what it is not. First of all, it is not a sacrament imparting special grace through the performance of a ritual independent of the state of the one baptizing and the one receiving baptism. Moreover, it is not a ritual through which regeneration occurs. While there are several difficult passages which seem to suggest that baptism does bestow grace and produce regeneration, a precise and accurate interpretation of those texts in the New Testament demonstrates that these passages agree completely with the rest of the New Testament’s teaching that salvation is by grace through faith.40

Second, baptism is not the final step of salvation. If it was, it would be introducing the elements of works and merit into the matter of salvation. All of Scripture (especially the epistles of Paul) uniformly teaches that salvation is a gift of God only through faith. According to a modest count, about 150 passages of Scripture proclaim this doctrine.41 For example, the apostle Paul reminds the Ephesians, “For by grace you have been saved through faith. And this is not your own doing; it is the gift of God, not a result of works, so that no one may boast” (Eph 2:8–9). Similarly, Paul and Silas answered the Philippian jailer, “Believe in the Lord Jesus, and you will be saved, you and your household” (Acts 16:31). Additionally, the biblical writers often juxtaposed faith as a condition for salvation to ritual and the works of the law.42 The apostle Paul wrote to the believers in Rome, “For we hold that one is justified by faith apart from works of the law” (Rom 3:28). Describing his experience, he explains to the Galatians, “So we also have believed in Christ Jesus, in order to be justified by faith in Christ and not by works of the law” (Gal 2:16). Thus the New Testament clearly and definitively teaches that salvation is obtained only by faith.

Third, in contrast to popular perception, baptism is not entering into some kind of covenant with God. Often, those receiving baptism in Russian evangelical churches declare, “I am entering into a covenant with the Lord!” What covenant are they referring to? Some assume that water baptism signals the entrance of a believer into a new covenant similar to the way in which circumcision testified to participation in the other covenants mentioned in the Old Testament (cf. Col 2:11–12). But a new covenant was promised only to the people of Israel (see Jer 31; Ezek 11); New Testament believers enjoy only its spiritual blessings. Furthermore, the comparison with circumcision of the heart corresponds more accurately with spiritual baptism rather than water baptism. Others say that the covenant is simply a promise to serve God with a good conscience (see 1 Pet 3:21). But it is better to translate the Greek phrase συνειδήσεως ἀγαθῆς ἐπερώτημα εἰς θεόν as “a request to God for a good conscience,” which makes baptism mentioned by Peter an expression of dependence on and trust in God that could fully be connected with conversion.43

In summary, although baptism is an important commandment, it is not a part of the gospel message, which is the power of God unto salvation (Rom 1:16). This observation is confirmed by the fact that during the ministries of Christ and Paul, baptism played only a secondary role (see John 4:1–3; 1 Cor 1:17). Nonetheless, there is no doubt about the significance of baptism as an important external symbol of an internal spiritual change which takes place in a person at the moment of conversion. It is a public confession of faith, the means by which we are made members of a local body of believers, and a commandment of the Lord Jesus Christ which every believer must fulfill (Matt 28:19–20).44

The Connection Between Conversion and Baptism

Nowhere in Scripture is any such thing as an unbaptized Christian discussed.45 In other words, it is simply assumed that under normal circumstances, all who believe receive baptism (cf. Acts 2:41). The only example of a person who professed faith in Christ but was not baptized was the thief on the cross who said to Jesus, “Remember me when you come into your kingdom” (Luke 23:39–43). In response, he heard the words of our Lord guaranteeing him eternal life: “Truly, I say to you, today you will be with me in paradise” (23:43). For obvious reasons, the thief on the cross could not physically receive baptism; nonetheless, he was saved by Christ.46

During the time of the apostles, water baptism was administered immediately after a person turned to Christ.47 The Book of Acts contains many examples of this. One of these involved the Ethiopian eunuch who, after he had believed the words of Philip, immediately asked, “See, here is water! What prevents me from being baptized?” (Acts 8:36). In response, he heard, “If you believe with all your heart, you may” (8:37). In similar fashion, the jailer guarding Paul and Silas who believed “was baptized at once, he and all his family” (Acts 16:33). The absence of a probationary period between conversion and baptism was completely justified under the circumstances which arose in the middle of the first century. Any person who was baptized took great risk, since a public confession of faith in Jesus might result in persecution from both Jews and Gentiles.48 The unconverted were afraid of joining the church. We read in Acts, “None of the rest dared join them . . .” (5:13). But the false conversion and baptism of Simon the magician indicated that a burgeoning problem of determining who was and who was not a genuine believer existed at that time (cf. 8:13 to 8:20–23). As a result of the close proximity in time between conversion and baptism, it is possible that the biblical authors may have had conversion in mind when they mentioned water baptism. For that reason, Dr. Thomas Schreiner, commenting on Romans 6, writes, “References to baptism were used to signify those who had believed in Christ. Since unbaptized Christians were virtually nonexistent, to refer to those who were baptized is another way of describing those who are Christians, those who have put their faith in Christ.”49

The Benefits of Water Baptism

So is water baptism a necessary condition for salvation? The Scriptures (including the difficult texts mentioned above) answer with one voice: No. Why then do the Scriptures clearly command water baptism for the Christian church (cf. Matt 28:19–20; Acts 2:38)? The biblical meaning of baptism answers that question. Water baptism symbolically testifies to a great spiritual reality.50 First, water baptism is a visual reminder of the gospel. It visually reminds us of the historic reality of the death, burial, and resurrection of Jesus Christ51 and produces joy as the gospel is preached to the one receiving baptism and those who witness it. Second, it is an external testimony of entering into communion with Christ. Water baptism testifies that a person has entered into union with Christ and has been joined to His body (cf. 1 Cor 12:13). It is the external symbol of the beginning of the Christian life.52 As a result, it produces the joy of salvation and greater confidence in Christ. Third, it is the visual representation of joining in fellowship with the local church. It is a public profession that a believer belongs to the local church and enjoys the fellowship of other believers, and it bestows on the believer the many privileges of membership in the church.

Conclusion

As a commandment of the Lord Himself, water baptism requires the obedience of every believer whenever circumstances do not create barriers preventing it. Furthermore, the Scriptures unanimously teach that salvation is a gift obtained by an individual on the basis of faith alone at the moment of conversion, and works of obedience which follow after conversion are not the basis of salvation but only the confirmation of genuine faith.53 Receiving baptism is indeed an act of obedience, a righteous deed; as Christ explained, speaking of John’s baptism, “it is fitting for us to fulfill all righteousness” (Matt 3:15). But because God “saved us not because of works done by us in righteousness but according to his own mercy” (Titus 3:5), water baptism cannot be the basis of our salvation.

Water baptism is therefore not part of the gospel. The apostle Paul purposely separated his evangelistic ministry from the ministry of baptism: “For Christ did not send me to baptize but to preach the gospel” (1 Cor 1:17). This explains why neither the Lord Jesus Christ nor the apostle Paul prioritized water baptism in their ministries (cf. John 4:1–2; 1 Cor 1:14–17). If baptism becomes a part of the Good News, it is no longer the power of God for salvation to everyone who believes (Rom 1:16).54

Upon precise and accurate exegetical analysis, the texts of the New Testament which at first seem to contradict the overall teaching of the Scriptures about the role of baptism in salvation are shown to agree completely with the rest of Scripture. Some passages have nothing to do with water baptism but describe spiritual baptism or some other spiritual reality about conversion (1 Pet 3:21; Rom 6:3–6; 1 Cor 12:13; Gal 3:27; Titus 3:5). Other passages contain a call to baptism but reserve the centrality of faith in the matter of salvation; they emphasize that salvation in general and forgiveness of sins in particular depend only on faith (Mark 16:16; Acts 2:38).

Russian believers and believers around the world need to diligently uphold these glorious truths and protect the gospel from being tainted.


Alex is the dean and New Testament Chair at Samara Center for Biblical Training in Samara, Russia, and an associate pastor at Transfiguration Church in Samara. He holds degrees from Samara Center for Biblical Training (MDiv) and The Master’s Seminary (ThM; PhD).


  1. 1.  See Jonathan H. Rainbow, “ ‘Confessor Baptism’: The Baptismal Doctrine of the Early Anabaptists,” Believer’s Baptism: Sign of the New Covenant in Christ, ed. Thomas R. Schreiner and Shawn D. Wright (B&H Academic, 2006), 189.

  2. 2.  See a good overview in Rainbow, “Confessor Baptism,” 196–200.

  3. 3.  See История евангельских христиан-баптистов в СССР [History of evangelical Christian-Baptists in the USSR] (Изд. ВСЕХБ [AUCECB Publications], 1989), 13. Cf. also Евангельские христиане баптисты. Сохранившие верность Евангелию [Evangelical Christians-Baptists: Those who remained faithful to the gospel] (Протестант [Protestant], 1992), 6.

  4. 4.  Russian Evangelical Christians and Baptists resemble Anabaptists, but it should be pointed out that the resemblance is only “to a slight degree,” since the Anabaptist movement was very diverse and incorporated a great deal of extremes and abuses.

  5. 5.  Andrey Puzynin, Традиция евангельских христиан: Изучение самоидентификации и богословия от момента ее зарождения до наших дней [The tradition of evangelical Christians: A study of self-identification and theology from its origins to the present day] (ББИ [Biblical-Theological Institute of St. Andrew], 2010), 207. My translation.

  6. 6.  “Prokhanov’s Confession of Faith,” Slavic Baptists, February 10, 2012, https://slavicbaptists.com/2012/02/10/prohanovconfession/.

  7. 7.  V. S. Ryaguzov, “От издателей [From the publishers]” Альманах «Кафедра», no. 3, Водное крещение [Water Baptism] (October 2010), 9. My translation.

  8. 8.  See Donald M. Fairbairn, Иными глазами . . . Взгляд евангельского христианина на Восточное Православие [Through different eyes . . . An evangelical Christian’s view of Eastern Orthodoxy], trans. Taras Dyatlik (Библия для всех [Bible for All], 2008), 12. Originally published in English as Eastern Orthodoxy Through Western Eyes (Westminster John Knox, 2002).

  9. 9.  Konstantin Prokhorov, Русский Баптизм и Православие [Russian baptism and Orthodoxy] (ББИ [BBI], 2017), 151. My translation.

  10. 10.  Fairbairn, Иными глазами, 149. Original translation. Cf. also Kallistos Ware, Православная Церковь [The Orthodox Church], trans. Galina Vdovina (ББИ [BBI], 2012), 284.

  11. 11.  See Ware, Православная Церковь, 285–86. It is important to emphasize that sacrament in Orthodoxy is understood in the following way: “A sacrament is an unseen sacred activity through which the grace of the Holy Spirit or the saving power of God is mysteriously imparted to a person.” Seraphim Slobodskoy, Закон Божий: руководство для семьи и школы [The law of God: A guide for family and school], 4th ed. (Molodaya Gvardiya, 1990), 548. My translation.

  12. 12.  Slobodskoy, Закон Божий, 548. My translation.

  13. 13.  See P. B. Togobitsky, “Крещение в Православной Церкви” [Baptism in the Orthodox Church], Альманах «Кафедра», no. 3, Водное крещение (October 2010): 121–22.

  14. 14.  See Togobitsky, “Крещение в Православной Церкви,” 126.

  15. 15.  See Ware, Православная Церковь, 288; cf. also Fairbairn, Иными глазами, 57, 146, 148.

  16. 16.  See Togobitsky, Крещение в Православной Церкви, 133; Fairbairn, Иными глазами, 152.

  17. 17.  See Fairbairn, Иными глазами, 56.

  18. 18.  See Slobodskoy, Закон Божий, 669–70.

  19. 19.  Prokhorov, Русский Баптизм и Православие, 135–36. My translation.

  20. 20.  N. A. Kolesnikov, Христианин! Знаешь ли ты, как должно поступать в доме Божием? [Christian! Do you know how you should conduct yourself in the house of God?] 2 vols. (Дружба и Благая Весть [Friendship and Good News], 1998), 1:44, 48, 49. My translation. Cf. Prokhorov, Русский Баптизм и Православие, 137.

  21. 21.  V. Kulikov, “Надлежит нам исполнить всякую правду” [It is fitting for us to fulfill all righteousness], Братский Вестник, no. 6 (1987): 11. My translation. Cf. Prokhorov, Русский Баптизм и Православие, 139.

  22. 22.  S. V. Sannikov, Подготовка к крещению [Preparation for baptism], 3rd ed. (no pub., 2005), 165. My translation. Cf. Prokhorov, Русский Баптизм и Православие, 139.

  23. 23.  Yury K. Sipko, В чем суть и смысл крещения [What is the essence and meaning of baptism?], (blog), March 11, 2012, http://ysipko.ru/v-chem-sut-i-smysl-kreshheniya/. See also Prokhorov, Русский Баптизм и Православие, 141.

  24. 24.  Prokhorov, Русский Баптизм и Православие, 140. My translation.

  25. 25.  See Fairbairn, Иными глазами, 152.

  26. 26.  The article by V. F. Martsinkovsky, «Крещение взрослых и православие» [The baptism of adults and Orthodoxy], was written and presented to the highest-ranking church officials in the 1920s. See its reprint in Альманахе «Кафедра», no. 3, Водное крещение (October 2010): 104, 111–112).

  27. 27.  Prokhorov, Русский Баптизм и Православие, 143. My translation. But cf. Puzynin, Традиция евангельских христиан, 412.

  28. 28.  See P. B. Togobitsky, “Значимость водного крещения для первых христиан,” Благомыслие [Right-mindedness] (2010), 99.

  29. 29.  Martsinkovsky, “Крещение взрослых и православие,” 113, 103. My translation.

  30. 30.  See Prokhorov, Русский Баптизм и Православие, 140; Puzynin, Традиция евангельских христиан, 482.

  31. 31.  See Mark Dever and Paul Alexander, Продуманное созидание церкви: Служение, основанное на Евангелии (Slavic Evangelical Society, 2009), ch. 10.

  32. 32.  See Koleskinov, Христианин! Знаешь ли ты, как должно поступать в доме Божием?, 1:50; Also see Lanny T. Tanton, “The Gospel and Water Baptism: A Study of Acts 2:38,” Journal of the Grace Evangelical Society 3, no. 1 (Spring 1990): 27; G. Michael Cocoris, “Is Water Baptism Necessary for Salvation?” Chafer Theological Seminary Journal 3, no. 1 (Summer 1997): 8.

  33. 33.  Togobitsky notes, “One of the peculiarities of the Orthodox interpretation of baptismal texts in the New Testament relates all incidents where the baptism of a Christian is mentioned to a church sacrament.” Togobitsky, “Крещение в Православной церкви,” 149. My translation.

  34. 34.  See, for example, Douglas J. Moo, The Epistle to the Romans, The New International Commentary on the New Testament (Eerdmans, 1996), 359; Thomas R. Schreiner, Romans, Baker Exegetical Commentary on the New Testament (Baker Academic, 1998), 307.

  35. 35.  See Walter Bauer, “βαπτίζω,” A Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament and Other Early Christian Literature, 3rd ed., ed. Frederick William Danker, trans. William Arndt and F. Wilbur Gingrich (University of Chicago Press, 2000), 164–65; “βάπτισμα,” BDAG, 165; “βαπτισμός,” BDAG, 165.

  36. 36.  See the brief overview of baptism in Floyd H. Barackman, Practical Christian Theology (Kregel, 2012), 426–27. See also L. S. Chafer, “The Baptism of the Holy Spirit,” Bibliotheca Sacra 109, no. 435 (July 1952): 201; William Walden Howard, “Is Faith Enough to Save?” Bibliotheca Sacra 98, no. 391 (July–September 1941): 360–71; William Walden Howard, “Is Faith Enough to Save? (Continued),” Bibliotheca Sacra 98 (October–December 1941): 489–501; William Walden Howard, “Is Faith Enough to Save? (Concluded),” Bibliotheca Sacra 99 (January–March 1942): 88–107.

  37. 37.  K. Boa and W. Kruidenier, Romans, Holman New Testament Commentary (Broadman & Holman, 2000), 187.

  38. 38.  See Gordon D. Fee, The First Epistle to the Corinthians, New International Commentary on the New Testament (Eerdmans, 1987), 604.

  39. 39.  Сf. Rolland McCune, A Systematic Theology of Biblical Christianity, 3 vols. (Detroit Baptist Theological Seminary Press, 2008), 3:272.

  40. 40.  For example: (1) A study of the general context and grammar of Mark 16:16 (leaving the textual criticism question aside) does not suggest that water baptism is necessary for salvation. To the contrary, the context and grammar point to faith in Christ, and this agrees with the teaching of Scripture that salvation is only obtained through faith. (2) In Acts 2:38, a better translation would be: “Repent (be baptized every one of you in the name of Jesus Christ) for the forgiveness of your sins, and you will receive the gift of the Holy Spirit.” In other words, Peter is emphasizing that repentance leads to the forgiveness of sins and the gift of the Holy Spirit. Mentioning baptism “in the name of Jesus Christ,” he is calling upon his listeners to confirm their repentance with a public act of obedience to the Lord Jesus. He is not talking about the necessity of water baptism for salvation. (3) Regarding 1 Peter 3:21, most commentators who are inclined to see water baptism in this verse must admit that spiritual baptism, the immersion of a person into Christ, saves the believer at the moment of conversion. That is precisely what Peter is talking about in this verse. (4) In Romans 6:3–6, Paul has in mind spiritual baptism which places a person into the Body of Christ, i.e., brings him into union with Christ and gives him new life at the moment of conversion. (5) First Corinthians 12:13 is referring to spiritual baptism and the Holy Spirit’s taking up residence in every believer at the moment of his conversion to Christ. It is this baptism which is necessary for salvation. (6) In Galatians 3:27, Paul is proving to his readers that their freedom from the law is based on faith in Jesus Christ through which a person enters into a spiritual union with Christ and identifies with His life, becoming an heir to the promises of God. The baptism mentioned by the apostle is of a spiritual nature and describes the moment of conversion and not the moment when someone participates in an external ritual. (7) In Titus 3:5, the apostle Paul affirms that God saves by means of spiritual purification (through regeneration) and spiritual renewal (through the activity of the Holy Spirit). The Greek word loutron relates to a spiritual reality characterizing the moment of conversion. Water baptism is simply not mentioned in this text.

  41. 41.  Among others, they include: Luke 18:42; John 1:12; 3:15, 16, 18, 36; 4:14; 5:24, 40; 6:35, 40, 47; 11:25, 26; 12:36, 46; 20:31; Acts 8:37; 10:43; 13:39, 48; 16:31; Rom 1:16; 3:22, 26, 28; 4:5, 16, 24; 5:1; 1 Cor 1:21; Gal 2:16; 3:7, 14, 22, 26; Eph 1:13; 2:8; Phil 3:9; 1 Tim 1:16; 4:10; 1 Pet 1:9; 2:6; 1 John 3:23; 5:1, 10, 11, 13; Heb 4:3; 10:39.

  42. 42.  See F. F. Bruce, The Book of the Acts, New International Commentary on the New Testament (Eerdmans, 1988), 70.

  43. 43.  The usual Russian translation of the Greek phrase συνειδήσεως ἀγαθῆς ἐπερώτημα εἰς θεόν as “a promise to God of a good conscience” is not consistent. Commentators and Bible translators disagree on the correct translation of the word ἐπερώτημα, which appears only once in the New Testament. It could mean either “a request” or “a promise.” But the first translation is to be preferred (cf. Wayne Grudem, 1 Peter, Tyndale New Testament Commentaries (Inter-Varsity Press, 2009), 171; Thomas R. Schreiner, 1, 2 Peter, Jude, New American Commentary (Broadman & Holman, 2003), 196; Caffin. 1 Peter, 137; J. Ramsey Michaels, 1 Peter, Word Biblical Commentary (Word Books, 1988), 216; Marvin R. Vincent, Word Studies in the New Testament, 2nd ed., vol. 1 (MacDonald Publishing, 1970), 656). The translation “a request” is the primary meaning of eperōthēma, as witnessed from the time of Herodotus to Josephus, who lived in the second half of the first century (see Heinrich Greeven, “ ἐρωτάω, ἐπερωτάω, ἐπερώτημα,” Theological Dictionary of the New Testament, ed. Gerhard Kittel and Gerhard Friedrich, trans. and ed. Geoffrey W. Bromiley (Eerdmans, 1964), 2:688. The verb ἐπερωτάω, from the same root as ἐπερώτημα, is encountered in the New Testament quite often and always with the meaning “to request, ask” (see Grudem, 1 Peter, 172; cf. “ἐπερώτημα,” BDAG, 362). Such a request made to God is equated to prayer. The translation “to promise,” in turn, has in its favor the support of the papyri (copies of non-biblical texts made on papyrus) where the word ἐπερώτημα is used as a technical term signifying agreement between parties, see J. H. Moulton and G. Milligan, Vocabulary of the Greek Testament (Hodder and Stoughton, 1930), 231–32; Henry George Liddell and Robert Scott, A Greek-English Lexicon, 9th supplemented ed., ed. Henry Stuart Jones and Roderick McKenzie (Oxford University Press, 1996), 618.; cf. Wolfgang Schenk, “ἐπερώτημα,” Exegetical Dictionary of the New Testament, ed. Horst R. Balz and Gerhard Schneider (Eerdmans, 1990–1993), 2:21. However, this meaning of the word is not testified in the papyri before the second century (Grudem, 1 Peter, 172). Furthermore, early examples of the use of ἐπερωτάω in contracts had the form ἐπερωτηθεὶς ὡμολόγησα, “having been requested, witnessed” (cf. a similar combination of verbs in John 1:19–20), where the function of the promise is represented by another verb (see Moulton and Milligan, Vocabulary of the Greek Testament, 231). The real reason as to why some prefer the meaning “a promise” is the desire to equate baptism to a contract or covenant that draws its analogy from Old Testament covenant symbols and the early Christian practice of addressing questions to those receiving baptism, see D. Edmond Hiebert, 1 Peter (BMH Books, 1992), 250; Peter H. Davids, The First Epistle of Peter, New International Commentary on the New Testament (Eerdmans, 1990), 145. The adequacy of similar parallels, however, raises serious doubts. According to the lexical analysis above, the Greek phrase συνειδήσεως ἀγαθῆς ἐπερώτημα εἰς θεόν is best translated as “a request to God for a good conscience,” which makes baptism mentioned by Peter an expression of dependence on and trust in God that could fully be connected with conversion (see Grudem, 1 Peter, 172).

  44. 44.  See Charles C. Ryrie, Basic Theology (Moody, 1999), 488; Millard J. Erickson, Christian Theology, vol. 3 (Baker, 1985), 1100–1101; Robert Duncan Culver, Systematic Theology: Biblical & Historical (Christian Focus, 2008), 988–90.

  45. 45.  See Schreiner, Romans, 310; Moo, Romans, 366.

  46. 46.  See Howard, “Is Faith Enough to Save? (Concluded),” 106.

  47. 47.  See John D. Grassmick, “Mark,” Bible Knowledge Commentary, ed. Roy B. Zuck and John F. Walvoord (Victor Books, 1985), 2:196; Louis Barbieri, Mark, Moody Gospel Commentary (Moody Press, 1995), 376.

  48. 48.  See James Montgomery Boice, Romans (Baker, 1992), 2:663.

  49. 49.  Schreiner, Romans, 306.

  50. 50.  See McCune, A Systematic Theology, 3:273–74.

  51. 51.  See McCune, A Systematic Theology, 3:272.

  52. 52.  See Wayne Grudem, Систематическое богословие: Введение в библейское учение [Systematic theology: An introduction to biblical doctrine] (Mirt, 2004), 1094, 1106.

  53. 53.  See Grudem, Систематическое богословие, 1108.

  54. 54.  See Tanton, “The Gospel and Water Baptism,” 28–29.

Copyright © 2026 by Aleksander Gurtaev and the Center for Biblical Missions at TMAI

cbm.tmai.org

Previous
Previous

The Unfinished Reformation: Spain, the Americas, and the Shadow of Trent

Next
Next

The Autobiography of John G. Paton (pt. 3): A Path Enclosed in Darkness